2009
Betting Against
We’re a little less than a month into running this site and for me at least still less than a year into talking rather publicly about my interest in these kinds of topics. The most interesting thing to me is that the reactions from people tend to land firmly in one of two categories – either they get very excited because they have also been considering this kind of stuff for a while and perhaps actually doing something in their own right, or they laugh and ask something along the lines of why we would ever consider stuff like this. Sure there are some middle ground people but for the most part that’s true. “Either you are really paranoid or I’m really naive” is a sentiment I’ve gotten more than once. And maybe that’s a fact, because the truth of the matter is as much as I want the future to be sunny and awesome with nothing ever going wrong, I just don’t believe things are going that way,and mostly I just hope things don’t go as badly as I expect them to. Some might say I’m betting against a happy ending.
That’s certainly one way of looking at it, but from my perspective I’m taking steps to ensure a happy ending. In the 34 years I’ve been here the list of things that didn’t work out the way they were supposed to, or the way everyone thought they would, or the way everyone hoped they would… well it’s a little on the long side. In fact even the things that have worked out well were often set into motion by something else not working out so well. And that’s certainly some of the driving force behind my approach to survival/preparedness – if something falls apart, I want to make sure I know how to take those pieces and build something with them. I think most people wait until something happens and then try to figure out what to do, I’m hoping to be a few steps ahead.
Neil Strauss, author of Emergency talks about similar reactions in a recent post on his blog. He writes about doing promo for the book and says:
In about half the radio interviews I’ve done prior to last month, the host has asked, with some disdain, “Prepare for what? What do you think’s going to happen?”
And then, suddenly, when the swine flu panic hit, those same people suddenly started calling and asking if I could do another interview offering their listeners survival tips.
Same thing happened after the California earthquakes last week.
We live in a world that seems to REACT to emergencies, rather than PREPARE for them. Leading to a situation in which the panic can be more dangerous than the disaster itself.
As a society I think we often take that reacting rather than preparing approach. If you follow security topics at all then you will be familiar with Bruce Schneier and this is the crux of his entire message. Frequently our approach to security (terrorism specifically) is to look at the last thing that happened and take steps to prevent it from happening again, rather than accepting that we can’t anticipate what the next thing might be and taking steps to reduce the effects of whatever does end up happening. It’s one thing if you are talking about passwords getting swiped, something else entirely if you are talking about where to get food in a crisis.
It’s also one thing to buy a bunch of gear and yet another to know what to do with it. That’s what I hope we pull off with this site, not only talking about the what but also the how and why. It’s not just about an earthquake that we know is coming, or the same storm we’ve been hit with year after year, it’s about the things we can’t possibly imagine. It’s black swan theory at it’s purest. Trying to have some kind of a leg up on the thing you can’t possibly predict. And sure, maybe there is a bit of paranoia mixed in, but in the highly unlikely situation that nothing ever goes wrong and we all live happily ever after, well, I wish that is what happened every time I was wrong.
- Interested in advertising on Urban Journal? Drop us a line.
-
Recent Comments
On the ForumsRecommended Posts
Archives
Categories
- Bug In (1)
- Bug Out (1)
- Disaster Prep (5)
- Food Storage (1)
- Housekeeping (3)
- Navigation (2)
- Networking (1)
- Reviews (7)
- The Basics (5)
- Training (4)
- What if? (2)
Resources

Comments (11 Responses)
Count me in the first camp though I wouldn’t say I was excited to be having to consider stuff like this. I’ve probably been reading too much James Howard Kunstler. I’m in a little different boat with two elementary school kids and one due in a month, but I’d be a piss poor parent if I wasn’t considering how I might prepare them or how I can protect them or how this might affect them. I’ve definitely always been in the “hope for the best, prepare for the worst” camp. I’m trying to strike a balance…do a reasonable amount of preparation within my means without going too crazy.
When I see people whose opinions I trust and respect (you guys, Bruce Sterling, Chip Rosenthal) doing things to prepare or at least thinking about it along with my own ideas of how things are going locally and globally, it seems prudent to do the same.
People who look at survivalists as the crazy, lunatic fringe tend to assume that we survivalists expect the worst to happen or even look forward to the worst happening. And I’m sure some do, but the majority of the people who want to be prepared when something bad happens aren’t looking forward to it.
Having seen bad things happen to large groups of people on a fairly regular basis, I understand it can happen to me. However, I wouldn’t want it to happen to me in a million years. (Alright, maybe the next hundred, I don’t really expect to live a million years.) I don’t want to be in a riot, or have my house knocked down in an earthquake or to be swept out to see in a tsunami, or to have the government stop working. But all those things have happened to people in my lifetime, and there is a (admittedly very slim) chance that they can happen to me too.
While I don’t expect or want any of these, or similarly bad, things to happen to me, I know they might. It makes some sense to prepare for them to some degree, just as a hedge in case they do happen.
people look at survivalists as the crazy lunatic fringe because so many of them seem to be! The trick is how to keep ourselves from being seen or labeled as One Of “Them” while still being ready & able to provide for ourselves
One of my earliest exposures to the need for survival preparation was reading the 1985 book, Lucifer’s Hammer. An extreme example of the total breakdown of society and government in the aftermath of a planet-wide comet strike. Very Sci-Fi concept, but it showcased some realities of fending for yourself, working together, and supporting your loved ones if the social structure collapses.
On the other hand, don’t worry too much about it. Most natural disasters are responded to fully within a couple days.
Fixer, I see it a little differently. I think it’s just the lunatic fringe that gets the attention, but I think there are probably a ton of people that have a little survivalist in them, but they just don’t get that much attention. I would bet that if you graphed out the entire population based on how survivalist they are, you would see a nice bell curve. Right in the middle, you would see a huge hump of people that have an earthquake kit but haven’t looked at in in five years. Those people aren’t thought of as survivalists, and they clearly aren’t the lunatic fringe, but they definitely have at least thought about the what ifs, and that’s where any of us start down this path.
I think this applies to a good number of things – the crazy people are the ones who get the attention because they are interesting. There’s nothing noteworthy about a normal person with an interest in something so people and media overlook them all the time, but the crazy one who everyone will notice and can point at will get the attention and thus seem representative of the whole group.
Hopefully with this site we’ll do a little bit of chipping away at that and show that a much wider variety of people have interests that intersect with survival.
True Grant, I think I should have said “so many of *THEM*…”, the mall ninja of survival with all the tactical gear who’s preaching doom and gloom about wtshtf. Those are the perceptions that stand out in the mind of an average person, at least it does to me.
Haha, oh mall ninja! One of the things I was thinking while writing the review of the Fenix L0D was that so far this site is gear heavy. Everybody’s going to think we’re gear queers. Just look at the forums and the discussion of bug-out-bags. I have a giant picture and list of everything that’s in my bag. But partly, it’s just so easy to write about gear. Really, it’s nearly effortless compared to writing a thoughtful article regarding a non-gear related topic. I guess I know what I’m going to be focusing on instead of doing gear and book reviews…
hope for the best, prepare for the worst
I think the “Law of Attraction” philosophy has served to justify and turn self-righteous many people’s disaster denial, as well as cause undue criticism of rational people who prepare for catastrophe. It is frustrating being part of a supposedly “conscious” community who, by and large, is very selectively conscious. Logically, the “LOA”, at least the way most people talk about it, is inane and, I think, very arrogant. People want to, on one hand, worship their “Mother Gaia”, and on the other hand act like ignoring her natural cycles and behaviors will somehow alter them. I find that disrespectful. I think that what is required of us at this point in time is that we live cooperatively with and prepare to be responsive to nature, rather than pretending nothing bad will happen if we don’t think about it.
Honestly, I could write a book on this subject and just may.
My e-mail signature has this quote from the I Ching, the oldest book in the Chinese canon, and the foundation of all Chinese philosophy:
“The wise one prepares for calamity by forethought.”
~I Ching, hexagram 63 (the image)
Leave reply